-
Who this checklist is for
-
Step 1: Write the duty spec before you contact a single supplier
-
Step 2: Match the supplier's certification scope to the equipment, not the other way around
-
Step 3: Require material certificates and actually trace the heat numbers
-
Step 4: Pin down the design code in writing — and put the edition number on it
-
Step 5: Define the battery limits on a single drawing
-
Step 6: Build the ITP with hold points before fabrication starts
-
Step 7: Lock in documentation turnover and spares before shipment, not after
-
Things that go wrong anyway
Who this checklist is for
If you're sourcing chemical process equipment — reactors, heat exchangers, columns, storage tanks, pump skids, or full modular units — and you don't have a deep bench of in-house engineers reviewing every drawing, this is for you. I've been on the receiving end of enough bad deliveries to see the pattern. The problems that actually hurt you aren't the ones your inspector catches at final acceptance. They're the ones that got locked in months earlier, at the RFQ stage, when nobody wrote anything down.
Seven steps. I run them in roughly this order. I don't skip step 2, even though honestly almost everyone does.
Step 1: Write the duty spec before you contact a single supplier
The duty spec is the boring document that says: what fluid, what concentration, what temperature range, what pressure, what flow rate, what corrosion allowance, what design life. It's the thing that turns "we need a 5 m³ reactor" into something a chemical process equipment manufacturer can actually quote against.
If you send an RFQ without this, you'll get seven quotes that aren't comparable and one of them will look suspiciously cheap. It's cheap because they assumed carbon steel and you needed 316L. Ask me how I know.
Minimum contents for a usable duty spec:
- Fluid composition (including trace components that attack seals or gaskets)
- Operating and design temperature / pressure — not just operating
- Required materials of construction, with a corrosion allowance value
- Design life and any cyclic service
- Applicable codes (more on this in step 4)
Step 2: Match the supplier's certification scope to the equipment, not the other way around
This is the one people miss. A chemical process equipment supplier can hold a perfectly valid ISO 9001 certificate and still have that certificate scoped to something narrower than what you're buying. I've seen a shop with a beautiful ISO 9001 wall certificate whose scope was literally "fabrication of non-pressure structural steel." They quoted us a pressure vessel anyway.
So: pull the actual certificate, not the logo on the website. Look at three things — the certification body, the scope statement, and the expiry date. Then check whether your equipment type falls inside that scope.
For pressure equipment specifically, ask for the code stamp authority. In the US that usually means an ASME U stamp for vessels under ASME BPVC Section VIII, Div. 1, or an R stamp for repairs. For European destinations, it means a PED 2014/68/EU assessment with a notified body, and the CE marking has to reference the correct conformity assessment module for your category. Verify the current edition of whichever code you're citing — ASME and PED revisions move.
Looking back, I should have done this check before the technical review, not after. It would've saved three weeks on a re-bid.
Step 3: Require material certificates and actually trace the heat numbers
Material certificates per EN 10204 come in two flavors you care about. A 3.1 certificate is issued by the manufacturer's inspection representative who's independent of production — usually the mill's QA department. A 3.2 certificate is issued by an inspector from a body independent of the manufacturer — a third-party inspector, in other words. The distinction sounds pedantic until you're in a dispute.
Here's the part most buyers skip: receiving the certs isn't enough. You need to trace the heat numbers stamped on the actual components back to the mill certificates, and confirm the chemistry and mechanical properties match your spec — not just that a piece of paper exists.
I still kick myself for the time I accepted a binder of certs without spot-checking heat numbers against the vessel nameplate. Nine months later we found out two shells had been swapped. Nobody was hurt, but the rework cost was not small, and my credibility with the operations team took a hit I spent a year recovering.
Step 4: Pin down the design code in writing — and put the edition number on it
"We'll build it to ASME" is not a specification. Neither is "to B31.3." Every one of those codes has multiple divisions, editions, and addenda, and the difference between them shows up in wall thickness, weld details, and testing.
Write it out explicitly. Something like:
Pressure boundary to be designed and stamped per ASME BPVC Section VIII, Division 1, [current edition]. Process piping within battery limits to ASME B31.3, normal fluid service. Heat exchangers to TEMA Class R. Rotating equipment to API 610 per the applicable edition.
For hygienic or pharma service, add ASME BPE and specify the surface finish in Ra units. Vague surface specs are the number one cause of re-blinding on sanitary skids.
Put the edition year on the purchase order and repeat it in the technical annex. When two documents conflict, your inspector needs to know which one wins — you can add a precedence clause for that too.
Step 5: Define the battery limits on a single drawing
The most frustrating part of chemical process equipment installation is the interface zone. The structural contractor blames the mechanical contractor, the mechanical contractor blames the supplier, and the supplier points at a scope matrix that says "by others" three times in a row.
Fix it before you sign. Take one drawing and mark every battery limit: flanges, terminal points, tie-in locations, utilities, electrical supply points, instrument taps, and control system interface. Next to each one, write a name. Not "contractor." An actual company or role.
The deliverables we've found most often dropped in the gap: anchor bolt templates, foundation loading drawings, motor terminal box locations, instrument air connection points, and lifting lug drawings. If your scope matrix doesn't mention each of these, someone on site is going to improvise.
Step 6: Build the ITP with hold points before fabrication starts
The Inspection and Test Plan — ITP — is a document, not a vibe. It lists each inspection point in sequence, tells you who performs it, and marks the critical ones as hold points that stop work if they aren't signed off.
The mistake I see constantly: buyers ask for an ITP at final documentation. That's too late. The whole point of a hold point is that it catches a defect before it gets buried under the next weld pass or the closure plate. If you didn't specify the ITP at the RFQ stage, the supplier will draft one that suits them, and your inspector will end up watching the last coat of paint dry.
Minimum hold points I'd want on any pressure equipment order: raw material verification, fit-up before root pass, hydrostatic test, final dimensional check, and preservation before shipment. Add third-party inspection — a TPI agency like your insurer's engineering arm or a notified body — at the same points.
Step 7: Lock in documentation turnover and spares before shipment, not after
Installation packages are finished by the paperwork as much as by the steel. If the MDR (Manufacturing Data Report) doesn't arrive with the equipment, you can't hand it over to operations, and you can't demonstrate code compliance to a regulator or a customer audit.
Specify the turnover package contents up front: as-built drawings, weld maps, NDT reports, material certs, hydro test records, calibration sheets, and the O&M manual in the language of the site. Specify the format — PDF plus two hard copies is a common ask.
Spares are the same story. Recommended spare parts lists often arrive three months after commissioning, and by then you've already had your first unplanned shutdown. Ask for the list at the same time as the technical bid, and negotiate the price for at least the first-year spares into the PO.
Things that go wrong anyway
- Changing the spec after the PO. Once fabrication has started, scope changes cost multiples of what they'd have cost at RFQ. If you must change, get a written impact assessment covering cost, schedule, and code re-approvals.
- Accepting verbal assurances. If your supplier promises a heat treatment, a surface finish, or a coating thickness over a call, put it in a variation order that same day. No signature, no promise.
- Underbudgeting the commissioning. Chemical process equipment installation and commissioning typically runs a meaningful fraction of the equipment cost itself — often more for skids with control systems. Whatever number the salesperson put in front of you, add a contingency for site conditions.
- Assuming a sourcing partner is always the answer. If your plant has an engineering department that already writes duty specs and code references, and you have standing relationships with fabricators who pass your audits, you probably don't need external chemical process equipment sourcing support. You've built the capability in-house. Congratulate yourself and skip the middleman. Where sourcing help usually pays off is when you're buying a category you touch once every few years, or when the internal team's schedule is already full and the equipment lead time is the real constraint.
None of these seven steps is clever. They're just what a chemical process equipment manufacturer, supplier, or integrator expects a competent buyer to ask — and what they quietly hope you'll forget to ask. Run the list once and the next RFQ you send will get answers you can actually compare.